What gets graded?
Four things: how worn the soles are, how creased the upper is, how far the color has gone, and whether the pair is holding together. Each is scored 0–100 against a written standard, weighted, and turned into a score out of 100 that maps to an A, B, C or D.
Why do some pairs get capped at C or D?
Because structure beats cosmetics. If the structural integrity scores a 1 the grade is a D no matter how clean the pair looks, and a 2 — or soles worn through — caps it at C. A pair can photograph beautifully and still be structurally done, and we'd rather say so than sell you a restoration that can't hold.
Who actually does the grading?
We do. Every pair is graded by Re•Store — you never grade your own shoes. You take the six photos and you're done; we score the four attributes against the written standard, and a Re•Store operator confirms the score before any shop sees the job. You see the grade and the breakdown before you decide anything.
Is the grade the price?
No. Shops bid on your photos, not on a number we hand them. The grade exists so you understand what you're paying for and so a shop can see what it's taking on.
What if I disagree with the grade?
Tell us. Every score points at a specific photograph, so there's something concrete to argue about rather than a vague impression. A grade you disagree with is a signal our reference photos are ambiguous, and that's our problem to fix, not yours.